Indianapolis · Est. Gourmet Deli
Hand-sliced meats, fresh-baked bread, and sandwiches built the way you like them — no shortcuts, no compromises.
From classic deli staples to signature builds — every sandwich is made to order with real ingredients.
New York Gourmet Deli started with a simple idea: serve honest, honest-to-goodness deli food in a neighborhood where people actually want to come back to. No fancy gimmicks — just quality ingredients, generous portions, and a friendly face behind the counter.
Located on East 21st Street in Indianapolis, we've become the go-to spot for lunch crowds, after-school snacks, and weekend family meals. Whether you're grabbing a quick hoagie on your way home or ordering a platter for a get-together, we treat every customer like a regular.
"Best deli sandwich I've had in Indianapolis. The Italian hoagie is loaded and the bread is always fresh. This is my lunch spot every week now."
"Ordered a catering platter for our office and everyone was impressed. Fast service, great prices, and the staff was super nice. Will definitely order again."
"My family comes here every Sunday. The portions are huge, the prices are fair, and the atmosphere is welcoming. It's our little tradition now."
Walk in anytime or call ahead to place your order. We're just off E 21st Street — easy to find, impossible to forget.
We're conveniently located on East 21st Street with easy parking and plenty of foot traffic.
9945 E 21st St
Indianapolis, IN 46229-1711
Mon – Sat: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sunday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
